It's a weird feeling out there even on a calm day. I've heard enough wild stories to get why the place creeps people out. The mystery just kinda hangs in the air, lol.
Ever check the local weather office for magnetic reports before you go out? I always pull up the nautical charts and double-check my depth finder is working right. A lot of those spooky spots have weird rock formations that can mess with your gear if you're not paying attention.