13
Spent 8 hours on a thumbnail that tanked immediately
I spent all day last week making this super detailed thumbnail with custom graphics and everything. I got like 12 clicks from it. The next video I just used a screenshot of my face and a simple text overlay and it did way better. Has anyone else found that simpler thumbnails actually work better for their audience?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
jana_fox502d ago
That "screenshot of my face and simple text" thing is exactly what changed my mind too. I used to think fancy thumbnails showed I cared about quality, but my best performing ones are just me looking surprised with one word on it. Sometimes less really is more when people are just scrolling past.
2
nancybailey2d agoTop Commenter
What's the deal with that though - why do simple thumbnails actually trick our brains better? I swear it's like we've been trained to ignore the super polished stuff because it looks like an ad, but a raw face makes us think "oh this is a real person sharing something real.
7
the_holly2d ago
Drop testing your own thumbnails and see what happens. I kept overthinking mine until I just put a straight up unedited screenshot of my face with yellow text and it doubled my views overnight. Your brain literally treats a glazed over expression and simple words like a signal from another human, not an ad, so lean into that.
4