S
15
c/baking-fails-and-winsfinleyh89finleyh892mo agoProlific Poster

Tried making a cake with olive oil instead of butter and the texture was wild

I was out of butter for a chocolate cake recipe, so I swapped in a cup of extra virgin olive oil. The batter looked fine, but after 45 minutes in the oven, the crumb was super dense and almost rubbery. I learned that olive oil has a different fat structure that doesn't trap air like creamed butter does. Has anyone else had a weird texture swap that actually worked out okay?
3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In
3 Comments
patricia_schmidt14
My friend Sarah tried mayo in brownies once and they were surprisingly moist.
1
lilykelly
lilykelly2mo ago
Wow @patricia_schmidt14, that's the secret ingredient logic right there.
8
wilson.kelly
wilson.kelly1mo agoTop Commenter
Okay but mayo in brownies is actually a thing! My aunt does it and they come out super soft.
5