My rescue pit mix had a perfect Saturday at the dog park and now I'm scared to go back
Last Saturday was the best day we've had in the 8 months since I adopted Rosie from a shelter in Fresno, and I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop. She usually gets nervous around big groups of dogs and will hide behind my legs, but that morning there were only four other dogs there and she just trotted around like she owned the place. She played chase with a little terrier for maybe 20 minutes straight and actually came back when I called her twice. Then she flopped down in the grass and let a stranger scratch her belly, which has never happened before. I was so proud I almost cried in front of a guy walking his corgi. But now I'm worried it was a fluke and if I take her back on a busy day she'll get scared and we'll lose all that trust we built. Should I keep going at the same early time slot or try a busier day and risk it? How did you figure out what setting actually works for a shy rescue?
Used to think you had to push a shy dog into busy situations so they'd just get used to it, and I gave that advice to a friend with a nervous beagle mix. She took him to a packed park on a Sunday and he spent the whole time shaking under a bench, then wouldn't leave the house for three days. That changed my mind fast. Now I'd say the early quiet slot is the actual win, not a fluke to move past, and you can test busier days in small steps, like showing up and just sitting on a bench for ten minutes without even going in. Rosie had a great day because the setting matched where she's at right now, so why mess with it before she's ready? What time does the park usually fill up on Saturdays, like an hour after you go or later?