Hot take: banned ads get judged on the rule they broke, not the idea they sold
I used to rate every pulled ad on this sub by how wild the clip was, and I missed the point until a 30 second spot I watched 5 times got me. The ad was pulled in 2019 for showing a guy chugging a whole bottle of hot sauce on camera, and I laughed and gave it a 9, then my buddy pointed out the grocery chain behind it never sold the sauce at all. So here's my two sides: one, rate the ad on the rule it broke, because that's the whole game. Two, rate it on whether the idea would have worked if they just cut the one bad shot. Which one do you all go by when a banned commercial pops up?