Hot take: our worst ad ever (a shaky phone clip of burnt toast) is the one that actually brought people in
Everybody in my marketing group keeps saying a bad ad is worse than no ad, and I totally disagree after what happened at our little bakery in Boise. Back in March we paid $600 for a clean, polished video with nice lighting and a script, and it got 12 shares and almost no walk-ins. Two weeks later our opener accidentally posted a 9 second clip he shot on his phone of a burnt batch of sourdough, and it hit 40k views in 4 days with people tagging friends and cracking jokes. We sold out of bread that Saturday and had a line out the door. The messy clip felt real and folks shared it to laugh with us, not at a sales pitch. Has anyone else had a scrappy mistake ad beat their actual paid campaign?